X
    Categories: Electronics

Best Shallow Mount Subwoofers – Buyer’s Guide

Music speaks to the human heart, but the rhythm is what speaks to its soul. Unfortunately, all too often the more budget-friendly audio setups focus more on the mids and highs which cater to melody and voice. This leads many people to seek out upgrades over factory systems which may lack the oomph in the lower registers.

Subwoofers are speakers designed to play the notes at the lower registers of music. They feature a much larger cone than other types of speakers that allow them to replicate the longer sound waves of bass notes. Of course, this can lead to a situation where they are designed in a way that takes up too much space.

Best Shallow Mount Subwoofers 2018

This is where the shallow mount subwoofer comes into play, but even in this subcategory, there is confusing differentiation. That is why we have put together a list of the 5 best shallow mount subwoofers. Then we provide a helpful buyer’s guide, so you can find the shallow mount subwoofer that is right for you.

ModelRMS PowerSensitivityFrequencySize 
Skar Audio EV-10
(Best Budget Choice)
150 Watts85 dB30 to 500 Hz10-Inch Check Price
Rockford Fosgate R2
200 Watts87 dB45 to 250 Hz10-Inch Check Price
Polk Audio db1040DVC
270 Watts86 dB20 to 200 Hz10-Inch Check Price
Kenwood Excelon KFC-XW1200F
350 Watts91 dB28 to 200 Hz12-Inch Check Price
Jl Audio 10tw3
(Editor’s Choice)
400 Watts82 dB24 to 200 Hz10-Inch Check Price

1. Skar Audio EV-10 – Best Budget Shallow Mount Subwoofer

As a brand, Skar is fairly new to the audio equipment market. Started in 2012 as the CEOs hobby, the company now employs twenty people and owns a 17,000 sq. ft. facility. Skar Audio is a full-scale operation that engages in research and development, product testing, and industry showrooms. As impressive as it may be, it does still mean that Skar Audio comes with some limitations some which benefit the consumer and some of which do not.

Budget Benefits

One of the biggest benefits of the scaled down Skar Audio operations is the effect it has on costs. Since the company does not have nearly as high of overhead as some other manufacturers nor do they have the name brand recognition, Skar Audio is forced to keep their prices low to compete with larger and better-known companies.

On the flip side, this also means that Skar Audio will have to cut corners where they can in order to stay competitive with brands that can simply buy in bulk and save on production costs. This most notably shows itself in the form of the EV-10’s speaker cone and magnet. The speaker cone is arguably the biggest issue with the EV-10 due to the fact that it is made out of pressed paper.

Drawbacks

Pressed paper is one of the lowest grade materials used for speaker cones and does not either produce the greatest sound quality nor have a robust structural integrity.

As such, the EV-10’s speaker cone will only produce okay sounding lows but is liable to rip and get blown if played at its maximum rated power setting. This is an even larger issue when you consider that the EV-10 has the lowest power rating we reviewed at 150 RMS watts.

Overall

Thankfully, you do not necessarily need to blast this speaker in order to get a reasonable volume out of it as its 85 dB sensitivity rating is decent for a shallow mount subwoofer. While we rated this as our best budget shallow mount subwoofer, this can actually be a good base subwoofer for those who like to tinker on their own.

Pros
  • Provides a decent sensitivity of 85dB
  • An exceedingly inexpensive shallow mount subwoofer
  • Rubber surround is great at this price point
Cons
  • An RMS wattage of 150 is low
  • Cone is made out of pressed paper
  • Magnet is a single stack ferrite

2. Rockford Fosgate R2 – Best Sealed Enclosure Shallow Mount Subwoofer

Started in the early 1970s and owing its success in a large part due to its ingenious founder, Jim Fosgate, Rockford is a power player in the automotive audio industry. In fact, it was Fosgate who recognized that human ears did not hear music the same way that early audio equipment produced it leading to numerous advances that ultimately increased the sound quality for all manufacturers.

A Top-Tier Brand

That being the case, it is actually somewhat disappointing that the Rockford Fosgate R2 is not more impressive especially considering the company’s top-tier product lines still lead the industry in numerous categories and remains a fan favorite of audiophiles worldwide. Still, this subwoofer does have a niche which is likely the source of some of its problems but ultimately makes it ideal for a specific setup.

Design and Materials

This subwoofer was designed from the start to be housed in a sealed enclosure. This is due to a few choice construction decisions that favor longevity over audio quality.

For instance, the cone is made out of mica-injected polypropylene for enhanced strength and durability, but the cone is simultaneously wired and woven directly to the voice coil. This allows the cone to replicate the sound without straining itself too much, extending the cone’s lifespan even further.

Unfortunately, this means that the cone itself is fairly limited in a couple ways due to its decreased flexibility. For one, this subwoofer features one of the most narrow frequency ranges of 45 to 250 Hz. While the 250 Hz as a maximum is not strictly awful, the 45 Hz low is the highest that we reviewed. This means that fans of hip hop, electronic dance music, and other genres noted for their incredibly deep notes will not have the full range of their voices heard.

Final Words

Of course, as a sealed enclosure subwoofer, the steel frame that is made with vents is designed more for the midrange spectrum of octaves. As such, fans of jazz, rock, and other midrange bass genres will find the R2 more than adequate for their needs. Though, the somewhat low power rating of only 200 RMS watts will still limit the maximum volume you can achieve. Thankfully, the 87 dB sensitivity means you do not necessarily need a lot of power to get a decent volume.

Pros
  • A reasonably priced shallow mount subwoofer
  • Excellent along the higher lows and midrange bass
  • Provides decent sensitivity at 87 dB
Cons
  • Has a fairly low power rating of only 200 RMS watts
  • Has the highest low at 45 Hz and a narrow frequency range
  • Sound quality distorts fairly easily

3. Polk Audio db1040DVC – Best Marine Shallow Mount Subwoofer

As a company, Polk Audio actually shares a great deal in common with Rockford Fosgate with a distinctly inverted approach. Similarly, Polk Audio also started with a scientist founder in the early 1970’s who understood that the audio technology of the day was not advanced in the subtle ways to produce audio the way it was meant to be heard. The difference being that Polk Audio actually focused on home entertainment systems rather than automotive audio at first.

Polk Audio Technologies

Sadly, this means that Polk Audio does not use the most cutting-edge innovations when it comes to their automotive audio equipment, though they are able to transfer much of their home theater innovations to the automotive market. Of course, when it comes to the db1040DVC, that is not the goal at all, as this shallow mount subwoofer was specifically designed to be utilized in marine applications.

As a subwoofer intended to be used on boats, the db1040DVC needs to pay careful attention to the risk of water damage. In doing so, Polk Audio made it a point to use some of the most durable materials found in audio equipment. The polypropylene cone is a common enough material used, but it is also one of the more water resistant as well. The ABS plastic cap may be rigid, but it too is water resistant. Finally, the santoprene rubber surround is a distinct improvement in durability over the more commonly used butyl rubber surround.

Overall

Altogether, these materials are designed to provide a structural integrity not only in moist environments but through a much wider range of temperatures as well. Of course, there is always a trade-off, and the more durable a material is the less flexible it is. In audio equipment, that rigidity translates to a lower quality audio. As the speaker cone struggles to properly replicate the sound wave of the bass note, its stiffness restricts its ability to do so. This manifests as a muted sound that does not have crisp edges and comes across as muddy.

Pros
  • Provides a decent sensitivity of 86dB
  • A reasonably priced shallow mount subwoofer
  • Materials are exceedingly durable
Cons
  • The largest mount we reviewed at 5 7/16” x 5 ⅞”
  • Has a narrow frequency of only 28-200 Hz
  • The stiffer materials produce muted sound quality

4. Kenwood Excelon KFC-XW1200F – Most Powerful 12” Shallow Mount Subwoofer

Kenwood is giant in the audio equipment industry that has arguably one of the most prestigious pedigrees. Originally established just after World War II in Japan, the brand originally manufactured radios. This focus allowed Kenwood to hone in on what decoding electrical signals required which ultimately led to the development of numerous technologies for various types of head units. However, when it comes to speakers, Kenwood first made their mark in the 1980s.

Quality and Branding

Because the products were made at an exceptionally high level of quality, the brand quickly became the choice for celebrities and consumers alike. Though, Kenwood has recently seen its reputation take a bit of a hit as the company is no longer known for pushing the boundaries of innovation. That being said, Kenwood does still understand what it takes to make a quality piece of audio equipment and brought that knowledge to bear in the Excelon.

While not the most powerful subwoofer on our list, the Excelon is right up there being able to make use of an impressive 350 RMS watts. Still, arguably one of the more impressive aspects of the Excelon is its peak wattage of 1400 watts. While most audio components are rightly judged by their RMS wattage, subwoofers should give a special note to peak wattage.

This is because subwoofers will often be forced to make use of high levels of energy in bursts rather than continuously. As such, a subwoofer with a high peak wattage as well as a high RMS wattage will be able to more forcefully and accurately reproduce both the punches and and booms of different music genre bass notes.

Intelligent Power

The Kenwood manages to do all of this with the highest sensitivity we reviewed at 91 dB per watt. This means that the Excelon will be able to produce equal volumes of music with much less power. Ultimately, this plays to the subwoofer’s advantage in a couple ways. For one, its maximum volume will be louder than many other subwoofers with higher RMS wattage rating but less sensitivity. Even better, you can get away with a less powerful, and less expensive, amplifier assuming you do not intend to push the Excelon to its limits.

Pros
  • High sensitivity of 91dB provides louder base
  • 350 RMS wattage is fairly high
  • Both cone and surround made out of quality materials
Cons
  • A fairly expensive shallow mount subwoofer
  • One of the larger mounts on our list at 3 15/16” x 4 7/16”
  • Does not feature a dual voice coil

5. Jl Audio 10tw3 – Most Powerful 10” Shallow Mount Subwoofer

Like many of the brands we reviewed, JL Audio was founded in the 1970s. Unlike many of the other brands though, this company did not begin as the brainchild of a scientist or two. Instead, JL Audio followed the path of Skar Audio in that it began as a hobby of the founders. They started by putting together component systems, trying to push them to their maximum capacities, and eventually started selling those custom units to friends and people they knew.

Modern and Powerfull

From those humble origins JL Audio rose to become one of the premiere manufacturers of automotive audio equipment riding high off of wins at numerous IASCA World Finals Championships where automotive sound systems are pitted against one another, comparing both sound quality and bass boxing. Following their smash success on the biggest stage of automotive audio competition, JL Audio took their specialization in subwoofer systems and expanded the business to where it is today.

The 10tw3 is a subwoofer driver designed for competition level performance in the shallow mount category. Even though this is only a 10” subwoofer it still makes use of more power than any other product we reviewed. The 400 RMS watts allow this subwoofer to blast bass louder than most. Moreover, with a minimum frequency of only 24 Hz, this subwoofer can accurately reproduce bass notes that are just above the minimum threshold of human hearing.

Great Sound, Slim Design

Though, this subwoofer is not really ideal for the midrange production as its frequency range tops out at 200 Hz. That is due in a large part because the 10tw3 combines the solid mica polypropylene cones with a butyl rubber surround. While this allows for decent sound quality and solid durability, it does limit the flexibility a bit reducing the fullest frequency range it might otherwise achieve.

Still, one of the best qualities of the 10tw3 is its mounting depth. Even in a shallow mount category, the JL Audio is slimmer than most, requiring a svelte 3 ¼” mounting both top and bottom. The JL Audio doubles up on its mounting focus by using a tab ear mounting system. These tabs allow multiple subwoofers to be mounted next to each other saving more than an inch in horizontal mounting space.

Pros
  • Provides the highest RMS wattage we reviewed
  • Can push the lowest lows at 24 Hz
  • Features one of the shallowest mounts on our list at 3 ¼”
Cons
  • A low sensitivity of 82dB will require more power
  • An exceptionally expensive shallow mount subwoofer
  • Has a narrow frequency of only 24-200 Hz

Best Shallow Mount Subwoofers – Buyer’s Guide

While the power rating of any speaker is important, it is arguably more important for subwoofers than it is for tweeters and mids. This is because a subwoofer is a much larger speaker with a larger cone. As such, subwoofers require more power to flex their cone and replicate the longer sound waves of bass notes.

Power

While subwoofer power ratings are gauged in terms of watts, there are two types of wattage ratings that apply. The first, and more relevant, wattage rating is RMS watts. RMS watts are a measure of continuous wattage use and are generally seen as the better category for judging a speaker’s power rating.

That being said, subwoofers are one of the few speaker types in which the second type of power rating, peak watts, is important. Essentially, peak watts determine the maximum wattage that a speaker can handle for brief moments. While mids and highs will generally play more or less continuously, subwoofers will often play intermittently depending on the music. In this case, a peak wattage can be important for punchier music.

Materials

When is comes to subwoofers, there are three general areas where the material is most important: the cone, the surround, and the frame. The cap may also be included in this list, but the cap generally has less of an effect on the quality of the audio produced as well as the longevity of the subwoofer in general.

When it comes to the speaker’s cone, this is the most important material consideration. The cone carries with it the unenviable requirement of needing to be both durable and flexible. This often leads to the use of complex plastics like polypropylene. For more advanced systems, glass will be combined with various woven fibers to produce a material that strikes the proper balance between flexibility and durability.

Woofer Surround

When it comes to the subwoofer’s surround, there are a couple materials used, but the best ones are always some kind of rubber. This is because the surround’s purpose is to reduce resonant vibrations that distort the quality of the sound produced. Lesser materials used for surrounds include different types of plastic, especially urethane.

In regards to the frame, this generally has more to do with the heat dissipating qualities than anything else. While low-end speakers will go with the less expensive plastic, that material traps heat. Similarly, steel will trap heat as well, though it is far more durable. Generally, the best material for a speaker frame will be some type of aluminum alloy that provides a solid structural durability while providing better heat dispersion.

Sensitivity

This rating is more accurately noted as a rating of efficiency, but it carries with it meaningful implications. For one, the more efficient a speaker is at translating watts to sound, the cooler it will remain. This allows the speaker to produce sound for longer without wearing out the material components of the cone or surround as quickly.

Still, the most important factor of a speaker’s sensitivity involves how much power it takes to produce a certain volume. As such, sensitivity is rated in decibels and determines how many decibels a single watt of power can produce. The more sensitive the speaker, the less power it requires to produce volume. In effect, two speaker’s of equal wattage but differing sensitivity will favor the more sensitive speaker for producing more volume.

Frequency

Unlike mids and highs, subwoofers are designed specifically to produce the lower registers of sound. The lowest sound a human ear can hear is capped at 20 Hz. Of course, there are many bass notes well above 20 Hz, so you should not simply look for a subwoofer that can play the lowest note and call it a day.

This becomes even more relevant when you consider the mid-lows. Mid speakers are generally focused on playing vocals and other melodic frequencies of music. As such, some of the higher lows played in music can muddy a mid speaker’s sound. That is why a subwoofer with a frequency range above 200 Hz can actually improve the overall sound quality of your audio system and can be an important factor depending on the genre of music you generally listen to.

Size

Subwoofers come in a wide variety of sizes which are judged based on the diameter of their cone. While modern innovations allow for smaller and smaller speaker cones to produce comparable audio quality, volumes, and frequency ranges, there is still no getting around the fact that larger speakers are generally able to produce a wider range of frequencies at a louder volume.

In terms of subwoofers, the most common speaker sizes are 10” and 12” in diameter. Still, subwoofers can come in sizes as large as 15” to as small as 8”. In fact, some subwoofers even blur the line between a woofer and a mid speaker at 6”.

Impedance

The impedance of a speaker is a measure of its resistance to an electrical current. This resistance is measured in ohms and ultimately determines how easily it can translate the signal from a head unit or amplifier into sound. Generally, a lower impedance will produce a better quality of sound.

This is because the digital signal suffers less distortion through a less resisted set up. Though, this does carry with it the greater potential of durability issues over time as the voice coil of the speaker will be handling a stronger electrical current.

Some speakers aim to alleviate this issue by providing dual voice coils or DVCs. The DVC allows you some leeway when choosing how to setup your speakers often offering the option of either a 2 ohm or an 8 ohm. Still, the most important thing to remember is to match your speaker’s impedance to that of your amplifier to reduce the risk of damage.

Conclusion

While everyone would love to have the best subwoofers available, that ultimately involves a serious financial investment. Though, that kind of investment will extend well beyond the subwoofers themselves. For this task, the amplifier and the head unit will also be major cost factors.

That is why the best shallow mount subwoofer cannot necessarily be judged exclusively on the audio quality produced. Of course, if you are looking for the absolute best audio quality, the JL Audio and Kenwood are great places to start. While the Kenwood cannot handle quite as much power, its larger cone and superior sensitivity place it on equal or better footing than the JL Audio.

Still, if you are in the market for a shallow mount subwoofer, chances are you do not have a wealth of space to work with. In that case, twelve inches might be too large and you would do better with the smaller ten-inch subwoofers from JL Audio. When you combine the smallest mounting depth with the ear tab mounting system, the JL Audio is arguably the best pound for pound shallow mount subwoofer we saw.

 

Derek Chase :Derek Chase is a 28-year-old car enthusiast. Currently working at a major startup company. Experienced in electronics and security systems. Tears down, repair, and rebuild power systems, exhaust systems, suspension, sound systems etc. of own cars. Read More.